eXtremeRate Replacement Custom Joystick Analog Stick – Carmine Red (PS5/PS4 All Models)
Product description
What this is
The eXtremeRate Replacement Custom Joystick Analog Stick is designed as a DIY replacement for PlayStation 5 and PlayStation 4 controllers, including PS4 Slim and PS4 Pro. It promises to restore the feel of the original thumbsticks while offering colour variety to personalise your setup. It’s aimed at players who want a practical solution to cracked or worn sticks without buying a new controller.
How it’s supposed to help
On paper, these sticks replicate the original thumbstick’s size and operation, so you shouldn’t notice a big difference in accuracy. The premium ABS material should offer durability for daily gaming, while the Carmine Red colour adds a visual refresh to your controller. If you’re comfortable with internal fittings, it can be a straightforward swap to extend the life of your existing gear.
What stands out
The main appeal is customisation without abandoning your current hardware. The ability to combine different replacement parts to tailor the look and feel of your controller can be appealing for players looking to personalise. The included screwdriver aids a DIY install, which may lower the barrier for those who prefer to tinker.
What might hold you back
It requires internal fitting, so it isn’t a plug-and-play accessory. If you’re not confident opening a controller, you could risk damage or a less reliable result. And while the description notes “works exactly like the original,” users should recognise that real-world results can depend on your handling and the fit of the shell.
Is it for you?
If you use a PS5 or PS4 family controller and have a cracked or worn thumbstick, this could be a practical fix that preserves your existing investment. It’s probably most sensible for those who value a personalised finish (the Carmine Red option) and are comfortable with a DIY replacement over buying a new unit. It may not be ideal for someone who needs a hassle-free, out-of-the-box swap or who wants guaranteed compatibility across every model without minor adjustments.
What to check before buying
- Confirm your controller model falls within PS5 or PS4 family (including PS4 Slim and PS4 Pro) to ensure compatibility.
- Be prepared for an internal installation, ensure you have a suitable workspace and the included tool is used carefully.
- Consider whether you want a single colour or a mix-and-match approach with other replacement parts.
Practical use: what you might actually do
Imagine your PS4 Pro controller with a refreshed, red thumbstick. Everyday gaming—racing titles or shooters—feels more like a fresh start when the stick is responsive and not sticking or wobbling. The real-world feel will hinge on how well the assembly seats in the shell and whether calibration is needed post-installation.
How it compares to other routes
If you prioritise keeping costs down and enjoy a bit of hands-on work, this replacement route makes sense versus buying a new controller. On the other hand, if the controller’s button circuit or casing is also worn, you may opt for a complete shell or a different approach to preserve overall reliability.
Final decision
Should you buy it?
It makes sense if you value extending your current controller’s life and enjoy DIY tweaks, and you’re comfortable with internal fitting. It may not be the best choice if you need a quick, tool-free upgrade or if you’re unsure about opening a controller.
FAQ
- Is this compatible with all PS5 and PS4 controllers? It’s described as compatible with PS5 and PS4 models, including PS4 Slim and PS4 Pro. Confirm your exact model and shell before proceeding.
- Do you need special tools beyond the included screwdriver? The description mentions the screwdriver is included to help, but you may require additional tools depending on your setup.
- Will the red colour affect grip or accuracy? Colour choice is visual, grip and accuracy should be dictated by the mechanical fit and calibration rather than colour alone.