eXtremeRate Replacement Custom Joystick Analog Stick for PS5/PS4 Controllers (Orange)
Product description
What it is
The eXtremeRate Replacement Custom Joystick is a DIY thumbstick accessory designed to fit PS5 controllers and PS4 family models (including PS4 Slim and PS4 Pro). It’s a practical, cosmetic and functional upgrade for controllers with damaged or cracked analogue sticks.
How it helps
On the surface it mirrors the original thumbsticks, providing a familiar grip and feel while giving you the option to customise colours. Made from premium ABS, the sticks are built for durability and daily gaming use. If your current joystick is only cosmetic or starting to wear out, this replacement aims to restore smooth input and a like-new reaction when you push the sticks.
What stands out
The product is positioned as a straightforward upgrade for compatible controllers, with easy installation aided by a screwdriver tool included in the package. The emphasis is on compatibility across PS5 and PS4 models, so you don’t need to buy separate parts for each console family.
What may hold it back
There’s an implicit requirement for internal fitting, which means some users may not want to open their controllers or risk minor DIY tasks. If you’re not comfortable with internal maintenance, the process could be a hurdle. Also, as with any third‑party part, feel and performance may differ slightly from the original thumbsticks, depending on the controller model and wear.
Who it’s for
This replacement is suited to players who want to refresh worn sticks, personalise their controller with colour, or build a customised setup without investing in a full controller replacement. It’s sensible for hobbyists who enjoy tweaking their gear and for those who value a practical, durable solution rather than a cosmetic-only upgrade.
Who it isn’t for
If you’re seeking a plug‑and‑play part with zero internal handling, or if you’re after a guaranteed identical feel to the original sticks across every model, you might want to consider official or OEM alternatives. Also, if your current controller is heavily damaged beyond the thumbsticks, a broader repair may be required.
When it makes sense to buy
If your PS5 or PS4 family controller has cracked or worn thumbsticks and you want to extend the life of your device, this could be a sensible upgrade. It’s also a good option if you’re after a colour accent (orange) to personalise your setup and you don’t mind the DIY installation.
What to check before buying
- Confirm compatibility with your exact model (PS5 compatible, PS4, PS4 Slim, PS4 Pro).
- Be prepared for internal installation, verify you’re comfortable with small hardware tasks.
- Consider how the orange finish will look with your existing accessories and shell.
How it compares to other approaches
For casual players, replacing only the sticks can refresh feel without the cost of a new controller. If you value a close-to-original input, there’s a chance of minor variation in grip or travel compared with the stock sticks. If you prefer a stronger upgrade or a higher-end control feel, you might weigh alternate upgrade parts or a full controller refresh.
A practical use case
Imagine you’re in the middle of a long gaming session and your thumbstick starts sticking or becomes unresponsive due to wear. Replacing with a fresh orange joystick can restore smooth motion and set a personalised tone for your setup, all without buying a new controller.
Final verdict
Is it worth it? It makes sense if you prioritise restoring functionality and adding a touch of colour, with a DIY approach that fits PS5 and PS4 families. It may not be the best option if you want zero maintenance or a guaranteed identical feel to the original sticks across every variant.
FAQ
- Will this fit my PS4 Pro controller? Yes, it’s listed as compatible with PS4 Pro and other PS4 models.
- Is installation difficult? It requires internal fitting, the screwdriver is included to help you access the shell.
- Does the orange colour affect grip? The material is ABS and aims to be durable, with the colour chosen for aesthetics as well as function.
- Can I use this on multiple controllers? The replacement is designed for compatible PS5 and PS4 family controllers, check your exact model for best results.