Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, Black 261 with Smudger & Sharpener

When a crisp line and a softly blended look both matter, this pencil keeps the two approaches together. The Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer is Black - 261, with a built-in smudger and sharpener. Its formula is described as waterproof, with wear of up to 10 hours. The listed finish for this option is creamy matte.

Getting the most from it

Use the pencil to draw a defined line, then reach for the built-in smudger when you want a softer edge. That makes it suited to looks that move between precise definition and blending, without needing a separate smudging tool. The sharpener is built in as well, so the pencil has an on-board way to maintain its point. For a simple everyday look, a defined line can be kept neat, for a more blended result, soften it with the smudger. These are two different finishes from the same pencil, rather than a requirement to apply it in just one style.

Strengths

The practical appeal is the combination of a waterproof formula with tools for shaping and blending. The product is described as colour-intense and long-lasting, with wear of up to 10 hours, treat that as the stated maximum, not a guarantee that it will look identical throughout every day or situation. Black - 261 gives the listing a clearly identified shade, while the creamy matte finish suits shoppers looking for a less metallic effect. Rimmel also states that all its products are approved as cruelty-free under the Leaping Bunny Programme by Cruelty Free International.

Worth considering if you want one eye pencil for both sharper definition and softer blending, and would value a smudger and sharpener built into the product. It offers a more flexible approach than a basic liner pencil without those tools. The listing describes this item as uncarded, which may matter if you have a particular packaging preference.

What matters most

This is a pencil-format eyeliner for adults, not a liquid liner or a separate eyeshadow product. Its stated benefits include definition and blending, so the choice comes down to whether you want to draw a line and soften it yourself, rather than use a product designed only for a crisp finish. The shade is Black - 261, the listing does not provide a broader shade selection for this specific item. If you prioritize a different colour, this variant may not suit that brief. Likewise, the up-to-10-hour claim gives a wear-time reference, but the supplied details do not specify performance under particular conditions.

Before you decide

Does this eye definer include a smudger and sharpener? Yes. Both are described as built in, supporting line definition and blending without listing either as a separate included item.

Is it waterproof, and how long is it said to last? The formula is described as waterproof, with wear of up to 10 hours. Individual results are not specified.

Is Rimmel London cruelty-free? The product details state that all Rimmel products are approved as cruelty-free under the Leaping Bunny Programme by Cruelty Free International.

Buying verdict

Choose this Exaggerate pencil if Black - 261, a creamy matte finish and the option to smudge or sharpen on the go match the look you want. You may want to skip it if you need another shade or specifically want a liquid format. Its appeal is the combination of a waterproof pencil and built-in tools, rather than a claim of a particular result in every wearing situation.