Revlon HU-XI-201 ColorStay Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner, 202 Black Brown, 2-Pack

A waterproof formula and rich 202 Black Brown color help create defined eye looks that are designed to resist transfer, smudging, and fading for up to 24 hours. The pencil glides on for a line that can stay subtle or build to a more dramatic look, while the built-in sharpener and smudger give you practical tools for shaping and blending.

This two-pack pairs a matte Black Brown shade with an easy-to-use pencil format for everyday definition or a more polished eye look.

What matters most

ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner combines intense color with a pencil that glides on smoothly. Draw a fine line for understated definition, or build the line for more impact. The shade is 202 Black Brown, and the product description identifies its color as matte. Its waterproof, transfer-proof, smudge-proof, and fade-proof formula is designed to last up to 24 hours, making it suited to days when you want your eye makeup to hold its look.

A built-in sharpener helps restore a pointed tip for precise lines, and the included smudger lets you soften or blend the color. That makes the pencil useful for two different needs: a clean, defined line when precision matters, or a blended effect when you want a softer finish. It is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for use on the waterline.

Buyers often praise the color, smooth application, and lasting wear. Feedback on smudge resistance is mixed, however, and some buyers mention that the tip can break or the pencil can feel dry. These opinions offer a useful sense of individual experiences alongside the product’s stated features.

Getting the most from it

Use the pencil’s sharpened point when drawing a precise line, then reach for the built-in smudger to blend the edge for a softer effect. The ability to move from subtle to dramatic definition gives you flexibility without changing the pencil. For waterline application, the product is identified as suitable for that use and ophthalmologist tested.

The built-in sharpener is integrated into the pencil, so you can refresh the point as needed without relying on a separate sharpener. A smudger is also built in for blending, making both shaping and softening part of the same pencil format.

Tips for day-to-day use

For a low-key daytime look, keep the line close and defined, for more emphasis, build it up or blend it with the smudger. Black Brown offers a softer alternative to a stark black line while still adding visible definition. The two-pack format is practical for keeping a pencil available in your everyday makeup routine and another with your other beauty essentials.

When precision is the priority, use the sharpener to maintain a pointed tip. When you want a less crisp edge, blend with the smudger. The pencil’s glide-on application and two built-in tools support both approaches, so the same shade can suit different looks and occasions.

Should you buy it?

Choose Revlon ColorStay if you want a waterproof pencil eyeliner in matte 202 Black Brown that can create either a defined line or a blended finish. Its sharpener and smudger are useful built-in details, and its waterline suitability adds another way to wear it. For anyone looking for a versatile pencil format in a two-pack, it brings color, application, and shaping tools together for everyday eye definition.