r.e.m. beauty Metallic Eyeliner Set, 4 Shades

If you want eye makeup to make a clear statement, metallic liner offers a different feel from a basic matte pencil. This r.e.m. beauty set brings together four Emerald City-inspired shades, with colors ranging from forest green and bronze to gold and silver. Each pencil is described as creamy and smudge-resistant, and the colors can be worn along the lash line or blended out for a more diffused look.

That gives you room to change the finish without switching products, though every shade has a metallic effect.

Getting the most from it

For a defined look, trace a shade close to the lash line and keep the rest of your eye makeup simple. For something softer, draw on the color and blend it out before it sets, the product is also intended to work as eyeshadow. A swipe of bright gold can add a reflective accent, while forest green with golden pearl or silver with green and blue pearl makes the color itself the focal point.

The four shades are Oz-mazing, a forest green with golden pearl, Oh, For Oz Sake!, a deep bronze, Follow the Road, a bright gold, and Tin Is In, a silver with green and blue pearl. If you prioritize an easy way to add color and shine, the liner-and-shadow use is handy. If you prefer a single-purpose pencil for a crisp, understated line, the set’s bold metallic direction may be more than you need.

Why it’s worth it

The appeal is variety within one coordinated set: you can pick a shade to suit the rest of your makeup rather than relying on one accent color. On a night out, for example, a short gold line at the outer corner can add shimmer without building a full metallic eye, for a more dramatic look, blending bronze or green across the lid takes the color beyond a conventional liner. It’s a great fit if you enjoy reflective finishes and want the option to use the pencils in more than one way.

The formula is described as long-wearing and resistant to smudging, fading, and flaking. Those are useful aims for makeup you want to keep in place, but wear can vary with application and individual skin. There’s no need to treat the claims as a guarantee of identical results for everyone.

Worth noting

This is a deliberately expressive color set, not a collection of everyday neutrals. The gold, silver, green, and bronze tones are the selling point, but they also limit how well it serves someone looking for a discreet matte liner. It may not suit you if you want a broad range of finishes or a simple black or brown pencil, neither is listed among these four shades.

The pencils are presented as creamy and blendable, so they suit both a sharper line and a softer, smudged effect. From the way it is set up, the main choice is whether you’ll use that metallic color often enough to make four shades useful. If you usually reach for a plain liner, a more basic single-shade option may be a better match.

Is it worth it?

Choose this set if you want metallic color to do more than outline the eyes and like the idea of blending liner into shadow. The four distinct shades give you several ways to build an Emerald City-inspired look, from a small reflective detail to a more noticeable wash of color. Skip it if your routine calls for subtle, matte definition or you expect a range of classic neutral shades. Its value for your makeup bag comes down to how often you’ll reach for shimmer, not simply how many colors are included.